good

a person spots some floating crates in the water filled with more food and rum

+1
score 42

bad

i eat it all

-1
Score 41

good!!

i make u throw it back up

+1
score:42.. AGAIN!!

Evil

I am stranded on an island and I am trying to get the attention of your ship. To get you to notice me I try building a catapult and launching a large boulder aimed next to your ship, in which the splash would signal you. However I miss and accidentally nick the side of the ship opening up a leak.

-1

41

Good, we patch up the leak and get more lighter. We can now sail 2x faster.

+1

42

Seeing as I failed to get the attention of the ship I launch myself using my catapult. I land on the captain who was checking some knots and break his arm. I am now onboard and the captain slows down while sailing so as to not have to turn quickly and hurt his arm even more.

-1

41

Evil!

The captains situation gets worse and he gets sick.

-1

40

Good!

The captain finds a mysterious remedy and gets better to full health.

+1

41

Evil!

But the captain drinks it and it does nothing!

-1

40

Good!

The captain suddenly finds another potion that revives him back to full health.

+1

41

But the ship is attacked by pirates and steal all the food

-1

40

The ship finds a huge cargo supply on a shipwreck and get all of the food and rum.

+1

41

Good!

The crew's energy is restored, and they continue their voyage!

+1

42

Good!

They find a cache of weapons at anoher shipwreck and become stronger.

+1

43

Good!

They clean the weapons up and sharpen them so they are more affective!

+1

44