I don't think I would play POTCO if it was a single player game. Because it would still be monthly, and chatting with other Pirates is pretty much the best part! So... no, I would not play PiratesOnline if it was a single player game. POTCO RULES THOUGH!

I wouldn't be playing POTCO if it was a single player game, I leave those to my XBOX 360. I like the interaction with people from all over the place and this game is better with more people.