The quest cant be picked up if your pirate already has it. And as for a full closet, i'm pretty sure even if it is full it will drop in there when you finish the quest.

Oh joy, a "new" piece of content that I can't even do <_< Thanks Big D!

YaY!!! Found Gildago..lolz
Now me alt has a brandy new Shirt!!!!

Never cared for the shirt and on a couple pirates I got ride of the shirt to get another one. I was hoping since I don't have the shirt no more I could do the quest and get it again but nope.

This reminds me of fathers day quest. D might have dropped the ball a bit here and screwed up something that could have been good. Different year different shirt would have been nice, Or give us pink or red hair for a select time like the green hair in march.

It is almost like the folks at Disney are just "mailing it in" now...

Quite a short little quest this one. Done it 4 times in an hour total maybe. Eh, it's nice to have the shirt, since I wasn't here last year.

Today at the Mardi Gras celebration I asked one of the GMs about Erin being in the EITC. Here is the chat:

Remember POTCO has new members joining all the time so they haven't yet seen the Valentines quest which might account for it not being changed this year.

Hi all, Im unable to pick up the quest for some strange reason. I sent 3 bug reports and feed back from the game. I think this happened last year as well. I dont know why potc can't get this thing right. it drives me mad! Not to mention I agree with everyone that stated that the V day quest should have NOT been the same as last year. BORING!
I can't believe im still playing this game with no new storyline questss. LOL I think ive waited a long time. Anyone know when they might add this? Soon hopefully.

I agree with Polly. I have alt pirates that weren't made yet for last year's quest. And many more pirates have joined since. So my ole pirate just quietly sat on the sidelines whilst me newer ones did the quest! If you check the ideal servers, there are many pirates who now don the Valentine's Day Shirt! So what is old to some is brand new to others!

I started my pirates in the spring of last year so the quest was new for me, but they could have made a new shirt and slightly changed the quest. They have different things this year for " valentine's day " in pixie hollow. They could have made a small change for loyal unlimited pirates that have stuck with the game for over a year. Make the shirt pink for girls.... and sleeves black for guys. Give out a heart tattoo. I do not know how much trouble it be to this but I think disney owes people that have stuck with them that much.