First one, definitely. Better story, didn't drag out forever like the second one did.

POTC2 was a lot better! Not only did it have more of an original storyline, but it was longer, made more sense, and had tons of more action. It was great!

I would have to go with POTC because that movie was good throughout the entire movie, while I did not like the beginning and ending of POTC 2. :)

I would have to pick the first movie because, it has a great theme. Yes POTC2 has a nice theme, but if you think about it it's not done yet POTC3 is going to be out soon. So, I can't really be rating POTC2 until I see POTC3 but right now I like the first one POTC!

~Cpt.Sea

I liked Dead Man's Chest better.

For me, Dead Man's Chest was better.

I enjoyed the first one. :)

I liked them both a lot, but to be honest, I liked the first by far. Though the second was clearly more intense and action-packed, it didn't have the same humor and great plot the first had. The second had its moments, but the first was much funnier and generally more entertaining, so I'd have to say the first.

they were both great movies to me;)

LOL Captain Blood. A great movie, but it really shouldn't count as it has absoluetly nothing to do with the actual POTC Universe. I voted At World's End - I can't believe that I'm actually more psyched for this than DMC!!!

I'm not going to vote until I've seen the third one.

My favorite would have to be Pirates of
the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black
Pearl. The special effects are really good.

The first was one was a lot more fun, in my opinion.
Elizabeth was too confusing in the second one >_<

I love both movies and I am really getting excited about the third one! But I like the original best.

I preffered the first. The second movie really got long and tiring towards the end. I can't say wether I would have chosen Captain Blood, however, as I haven't yet seen any Errol Flynn flicks.