My very first pirate was male, but it just didn't fit-so I deleted said pirate and now have all wenches that play.

I've seen both and I play both... Eliza is still my favorite. And her player (me) is a guy. I also play her brother John and a guy named Bucky. She's been my only girl, save for little Eliza T. Creststeel on Test, who was designed to look like Eliza as a younger woman.

The thing for me - is not to lie about it. I act as Eliza's personality, but I never pretend that I'm a woman behind her toon. That's where things can go wrong. It's not a secret in my guild or with my friends either.

Someone asked me why she's my favorite and I think for two reasons - 1) Eliza has a distinct personality and she's likeable. 2) If I have to look at a pirate on my screen for hours at a time, maybe its better that shes easier on the eyes.

i have 3 guy pirates and 1 girl pirate.

Mastered (back when mastered was 40) my "main" pirate Jason, but since then I only log on as Gabriella. A lot easier to get help and meet nice people as a female pirate.

I recently just made two female pirates, Esmerelda Fireskull and Venus Fireskull. Both basic and levels two and four, but its interesting. I'm curious to see if I get any people drooling after me, as I tried to make them somewhat attractive.

person: Wanna be my GF?!
me: I'm a guy....

That would be funny...

I personally prefer making pirates of my own gender....I have tried making a male but some how it felt wrong for me to be playing a male when I am female....but that's just me! I have lots friends that play both and that's fine!

My only lvl 50 is a girl even though im a guy lolz The rest are guy pirates.

I made three. Two were deleted by hand, and my favourite was deleted by Disney.