The game doesnt feel like a movie at all. For example, what i didnt get was why did they add the Queen Anne's Revenge before the Davy Jones storyline. They have been promising us that for years now.
Another thing I didn't get is why did they added Jolly Roger when he has no meaning to the movies, I know he is the main bad guy here, but i still think they should actually add the storyline of the movies. So far they only have the first movie as a quest, to retrieve back the Black Pearl.

It feels nothing like the movies, but I think that that is a blessing in disguise. Think about it, the only thing that keeps some of us playing is a new storyline that might be the final battle with Jolly Roger. Some of us like the fact that there will be a separate storyline in the future, even though we will probably be errand boys/girls like we are in the Black Pearl storyline. While some people want to have another cheap short quest like RC, but for Blackbeard and the 4th movie, I want to finally kill Jolly Roger. Or at least progress the story a little bit. :P

The POTCO Staff keeps releasing "Stall" Updates, that frankly seem pointless to me. They release something small every 2-3 months to keep us happy. I'd rather wait 6 months to get something that revolutionizes the game then have to wait 12 because they're busy making stalling updates as well.

I don't really want it to be just like the movies. Games based off of movies are not very appealing to me. Just I feel like I'm just a normal person walking around Port Royal when really I'm a villanous criminal who has killed thousands of people. Since when can they walk down streets and not have a worry?