Aye i'd say ship customization, it would help with your style of sailing!

any thing would be good........being able to have more than 4 pirates .......not much to do when u lvl all 4....lol

Lets see.. all of the above but more islands and ship custimization mainly

I'm confused as to why toontown lets us hold six toons but pirates will only let us have four pirates.
It probably has something to do with lag.

More lvl Cap (e.g. lvl limit to 99 as most online games have)....To be honest, All of the Above.

Though I agree with the raising with Noriety - 99 is a bit unrealistic at this time of the game... even WoW has just raised theirs from 70 to 80 with their Expansion Pack Released a few weeks ago - and the amount of content they have is 50 x more than POTCO...

I would like to see it all :D but it all has to raise in balence (more Storyline, raise to 50, add content, raise to 60... so on and so on :) )

I voted more islands, ship customization, more stoy quests, new ship flags, more ship classes, new weapon types, and more special effects.