I gave POTC an D. I never asked for anything, well maybe except the Kraken, but I am patient. The beginning of the year was great! New islands, higher level caps, the lag seemed to decrease for a while...etc. Then the invasions were fantastic and its was fun looking forward to them coming, great idea! And the 3-D glasses... AWESOME! But as soon as December hit, I could'nt log on at all. Some update made it so I cant even log on. :( This got POTC a D. You almost failed, but the early part of the year helped you pass.

Considering they haven't added much to the game it gets a B from me. Mainly because of lag that was fixed from 2008 (long time founder) and also some cool things were the new maps, and invasions are my absolute favorite

-Jack