What ship to buy? What ship is best?

These are things that input from others can help one decide. May help bring forth facts about each you are unaware of for example. But when it comes right down to it. Its a matter of preference. A pirates individual preference should take precedence, keeping the feedback from others in mind but taken 'with a grain of salt' as they say, because thier feedback is in no small part based on THIER preferences as well.

There is just as many people that will swear by the War Frigate, as there are that will swear by the War Galleon, as there are that will swear the War Sloop.... and so on...

Personal preferences, play style, sailing style, and preferred sailing tactics will determine this in the long run. Other pirates do not know how YOU like to play, sail, etc. So although thier input may be informative, and helpful, it should never be considered as the determining factor.

That being said... I really really really love War Galleons.

If you want to drive a bus get the war galleon it is soooooooo slow! lol
me? I like the war sloop but thats second favourite to the war frigate