The thing where, if you shot a cannon at a sail, the cannonball - no matter the type - would go straight through the sail, continuing to do damage to the sails beyond, and possibly hitting the hull.
( Come to think of it, did Explosive ever do that? I never had the thought of shooting a bomb at a mast. Curses... )

bugs bunny would never be in the game haha

Any Marvel character ...

Attachment 2643 Elmer Fudd, then?

Woo Elmer! The ability to make yourself the pirate in real life...

The ablity to verify your age and have unsensored chat with fellow guildies

The second story quest

Adult only servers

The ablity to make someone walk the plank

The ability to have Pixie Dust and Fly around the caribbean. lol :):laughks2::bookishfj7::piratewheelgo2:

Checklists for Weapons.

Flying monkies!
What can I say? I like the Wizard of Oz lol

melting witchs *ahhh! shes melting melting what a world what world* haha

GMs that say:
"I will miss you most of all, scarecrow."

the tin man haha

Unicorns rofl

any animal that we can ride

eye patches

motor boats

Ship of the lines for pirates

ship of the lines that go around normally, even when there is no treasure fleet

Axes

Eating to survive

Swimming from island to island

Staffs for basic

Oprah

Dodos

parents

Number availability in Chat

money lying all over the place

i could go on...