Am I that guy?

A turnip.

Doing this freakin' algebra :/ and HERE!!!! :D

SHARKEHHHHHH :D

YES!!!!!!! And no Davy, you are not my Treasure Room looting buddy... 0_o

PIB2?

Nadda.

People with initials! PIB2, DF, TSC, CS, or maybe, just possibly, a 1 in 10000000000 chance... E K B!

EKB fails :p

The shipsteel dood :P

Never heard of Dood.

PIB2, who insults EKB, and risks death.

Yus!!! It iz I Pibby dood :D

Wackie Jackie

No! Pib, you must come looting wit me again! You must go on.

PIB2? Or teh Jackie?

Pibby boy is online right now!

SHARKEEEEEEEEEE :D

WrongEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE! It is I, NateYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!

The Pibster. Ooh! Mr. Pibb! Fridge raid time!

No, but I will gladly raid a fridge with you.

Nate.

You know that I must post when my name is said, oui?

Davy or Pibster.

Pibster? I like it :D

The Nateanator

No. That is not my name. I am not even gonna reply to it. In fact, the Pibster is over. Boom. Just like that. You saw what I did there. It even tells me so.

The Pib Master or Davy.

Hello.

Pibster (is back).

No... I don't recall going by that name.

Lurking Nate?

Nuuuu :D and get on my tormenta treasure room looting buddy xD

SHARKEHHHHHHHH

Yes... You are unusually correct. Ok ok I get on.

Lurking PIB2?

Oh, uh uh. Nada, no. Poof. No. Not Pibster.

SHARKEHHHHH

lie pie!

DAVEHHHHHH

Nay...

Still lurking Pie?

No. No. No. No. Nope.

YOU........

:O you found me!

That person!

I am no person. I am iPirate.

You again! *gasp!*

Dang boy! You is good at this math stuff!

El iPirate?

Wrong. I went back to Swordwalker exactly..... 12 seconds ago.

Let me guess.... You.... Or maybe him.... But probably you....

Wow, UFAIL. What happened to your skillz?

YOU!!!!!

Nope, I am me, not you. See my logic? :p

ME.

No. Cuz ur logic is fail :D

Me? Or You? Either one, I'm right :)

No, actually, you didn't think about it... You put the 2 answers that I put first, and then you thought it actually made sense without using any logic skillz at all!

Him.

Who? That guy? See, your logic is still not logical logic, therefore, u iz fail :D


Still awaiting Captain Turnips!

You see, not logical logic would be impossible to comprehend. Basically, my logic is not making any sense at all, leaving you dumbfounded and sitting at your computer for 5 minutes trying to come up with an answer to my logical post. Ha.

Pib.

Dumbfounded? I've just gotten started. You see, if your logic is not making sense, then why is it logical logic, that isn't logic? Or is it still the logic that you thought you could understand, even though it made absolutely no sense? Oh yea, its me :)

Nate

Corriger. Je devais vous donner le temps de réfléchir sur les erreurs que vous avez fait.

PIB2

Have fun.

Kein Französisch o_O Und nein, ich machte keine Fehler :p

Nate

Have fun :)

What language are we speaking???? And Nope!

NATE?

Du denkst, ich kann nicht gelesen? Who cares! Sie haben einen Fehler machen, wenn. Sie sprachen in einer anderen Sprache!

PIB2 (guess)

Sharky, really.... (P.S.)

Yes! You got it! Are you speaking German?

Nate?

Sind wir? :P

SHARKEHHHHHH

Nei. Giska á hvað ég er að tala núna ....

Shark or PIB2

Gosh this is annoying me...

PIB or Nateh?

Да. Забавлявайте се четене този един!

Sharkeh or PIB

Yes... Guten tag? Wie geht es ihnen?

Nate.

Yep. I'm done speaking indifferent languages...

PIB2 or Sharkeh

THANK YOU!

SHARKEHHHHH ( but probably boring old nate :/ ) LOL

Ah Danke schon Nate!

Yes correct
Nate??

No.

SHARKEHHHHH

ufail.

DAVEHHHHHH

mmmmm.

DANIELEHHHH

Yahhhhhhhh :D

DAVIDEHHHHH

Dahhhh

PIBBEHHBOYTOOOOOOO

........:D

Davehhhhhh Freskllllllllll

Yes!

Dr. Zeppers.

Wow, terrible guess my friend o_O

Zeppers :D

No.

Hi Zeppers!

NO. Pie :D

TURNIPS!

I guess Davy.

You guess incorrectly.

I guess... A Shadow Sorcerer.

Completely incorrect. Anyways, you gotta be more specific. I think.. Davy Fireskull.

I think.. Not

How about a Jack Shipsteel?

Not a Jack Shipsteel. THE Jack Shipsteel. Although, I have met another Jack Shipsteel before....

An Inmate of the GP Prison. Or a soon-to-be one.

You have failed, for we all know I'm never going there.

A Guard of the GP Prison.

No, I am an inmate of the GP Prison.

Crest?

Nope. Nate.

Crest?

Nope.

Lurking Crest?

No. Lurking Nate.

I see you.. So I guess it is you...

You are correct my friend....

Nate again?

Naaaaaaaaaay.

SHARKEHHHHH

NEIGH. I'm a doggy :D

DAVEHHHHHHHH

NAAAAAAYYY

PIEEEEHHHHH! Why are we talking like this?

I'm not XD

sharkytooth

I no no one named sharkytooth...

Teh King of Seas?

Please Try Again. After depositing 25 cents.

Sharky, with my finished Drink Replicator.

Erm, no Drinky Replicator yet. Check the rummy game.

Angry Jack?

Btw, I will be busy today, so idk if I can finish it today either...

/flee

No! Angry Nate!

Cresty.......................................

surprise!!!

um sharky..?

YES! Grats to your amazing guessing skills...

Angel, who has decided to post on the activities again?

A two-month phail!

Stealthy, trying to recapture the activites.

Jack.... look whos here!

Jack...

Nope!

Davy Fireskull?

Nope.

Jack?

Wrong as usual...

SC is next.

Ya think? lol

Some guy../.

Nope. Ooh, we decided to start playing this again...

SC.

What throne? You are nothing but the jester!

SC is next.

Until you name an actual someone, no.

TSC?

Close you need one T in there.

TSC will return.

You didn't see that coming, did you?

Stealthy Cannoneer is next

I am never wrong...

Some kind of noob is next.

I ain't no noob 0_o

Davy?

Yes you are. You forgot to guess who's coming next.

Sharktooth.

I couldn't resist posting >_<

Davy who feels the same desire?

Drats.

SC....