1) A "Gift" button so that we can gift items to other mateys.
2) Ship constumization: enable broadside to shoot thunderballs-fury-fireballs, ship names, flag for ships.
3) Bigger Weardrobes.
4) Level cap increase along with more enemies and more weapons introducing a "Rifle" or "shutgun"
5) Davy Jones enemy flag ships (that would be great to board one and fight some molusks etc).
6) New Jewelries: Necklaces and Bracelet. Specially, for the girls...I know they would love it...and us too..see them wearing them
7) Jack Sparrow's hair style
8) New islands: Isla Murcielagos, Wild Wind Island.
9) Provide Option to the captain of the ship where he would be able to grant permission for someone to take the wheel.
10) And last, but not least:
A designated (dedicated) PvP server where anyone who wants to play PvP should go there. This will eliminate most of the lag and specially those who are abusing the Abassa Server with the PvP glitch.

Merry Christmas!!!! and Happy New 2009!