Heya jason. Please don't delete the guild if you don't like my ratings.
Big John: I think he looks pretty good. The jacket and shirt go well together. He could do with a bowtie though. My rating: 9
Gabbie: Clean kept, good jewelry. The colors are blended well with the belt
My rating: 9
Jason: Looks very much like a sailor or pirate. Could use a different vest, something a bit darker to provide contrast.
My rank: 8
Overall rank: 8.6666666, which rounds to 8.5