First off let me start by saying I be a fair judge. I'm gonna be a little harsh but hey.. that's fashion lol. Just keep in mind not to take your scores to heart.. i be judging on the outfit.. not the person. Also keep in mind I'm trying to tough 
Usually I'd be a pushover and just give ye all 10/10's LOL.. (because so far they are all really quite amazing!)
Okay, so lets start with jason:
Big John- I must say, this outfit is very dashing. Although you lack in tattoos and jewelry, i feel as if this outfit doesn't need it. Overall I say 8/10
Gabs: The color contrasts with her skin tone nicely, also brings out her eyes. Simple outfit, but again.. it works. A tad original so i'm going to have to say 7/10
Jason: Very piratey outfit. Not sure I love the vest though. It doesn't seem to fit with the outfit. I feel as if he could have a little more creativity with his wardrobe. I say 5.5/10.
TOTAL SCORE: 6.8/10
Next, Miratto:
Sven: Interesting combination. I definitely get tough ship pirate captain from this look. I like how the tatoo kind of mathes with the outfit as well. Creativity is definitely show in this piece. 8/10 for you....
Molly: I'm just not feeling this outfit. It's a little bland to be honest, and the matching could be a little better. I do admire the uniqueness though so i will give you a 5/10.
Ben: I like the contrast of the blue and the black pants. In fact it's a really amazing combination. Not a big fan of the hat.. the boots could be better.. love the tattoos. Overall i say 8/10... nice outfit!
TOTAL SCORE: 7/10
And up next, Piratepeople9:
Sam Plankmonk: I am a big fan of Barbossa's outfit! I just love the way it looks.. I like how you added your won touch too it with the vest, belt, and boots! Very dark and tough looking! This outfit says, "mess with me.. mess with my blade" Love it! But creativity wise.. there is a lot of Barbossa's outfit in there... So your score is gonna be lowered a tad.
TOTAL SCORE: 7.5/10
Great job so far guys! Looking forward to seeing some more of these buccaneer ensembles!
