[Plunderin Mom]

Yes, thats' the one. The first place I looked was over by the trap door, too, because that's where I'd found it in Beta. When it didnt give up the goods, my friend and I began searching in other dig sites and even dug in the spot by the trap door once or twice more. We searched a few more sites, and some of them several times. She finally found it, and I went over and tried. It didnt give it to me immediately, but did on the second attempt.

Last night another friend was having the same problem and I recommended she try digging in the same spot a few times. After several attempts in the same location she found it, but not sure which location that was.

I had the same problem digging up treasure for Karbay on Tortuga yesterday that I had found easily in Beta. Im beginning to think it might be random (and that any dig spot could work as long as you're on the right island), just as some will capture somebody off a ship on the first attempt and for others it may take many.