[The.Grand.Nagus]

Ok, so the game takes place in a "parallel universe", rather than in any specific movie's time:

"We’re building a parallel universe, so we haven’t locked our game to a specific point in the timeline of the films. We want the world to be as thrilling and rich as possible and we thought the best way to do this was to draw upon all of the best characters, enemies, settings, and events regardless of their location in the movie timeline."

That being the case...I'd like to see Davy Jones