Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr. Zeppers
Your absolutely right the cell phone part was a stretch, but that in itself was the point. ....
If you are debating over whether or not to allow VOIP use in TBC events, then I recommend everyone consider some facts (further contemplation on how to apply the 3rd party application is not facts, only opinions, mine included).
VOIP in itself does not warrant banning (per the games staff, since they are the governing body, going above them is unwarranted) (A member called and verified this)
VOIP can give an advantage over teams/players not using it. (However, if all are free to use it, its a choice. Should some peoples choices dictate others choices?)
May TBC prosper...
|
Yess ZEP it is your OPINION as all these posts are opinion... AGAIN PLS DO NOT MISUNDERSTAND THE POINT, I feel a few are being altogether tooo defensive here, probably because the lines on interpretation of the TOS are all too blurred
BUT to stress:
NO ONE IS TRYING TO GET ANYONE BANNED, that isnt about pirating either and all Im interested in is PIRATING.
A REMINDER:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pirate Bood
...ok for those of you commenting on this thread that think it is ONLY about the use of other prgs for voice and chat that is the issue here, AS IF that isnt big enough on its own, I would like to remind you that this issue was raised because of an event that was held last tuesday and at the time was not a TBC event.
...''...In the cold hard light of the event, the organiser took the captains from their crews at short notice prior to the sail to give them rules, leaving little time for the information to be passed on before the event, they were not allowed to crew with their ship mates making communication without team spk/chat prg awkward.''
...I felt belittled over seeking reassurance regarding non use of team spk or other chat prgs. I for one, and there are many like me, am not prepared to break disney rules on 3rd prty prgs and it simply isnt practical or fair to make us feel that we have to do it to be in with a chance of competeting.....'
....If you do not agree with the disney rules or the straightforward interpretation of them, then take it up with disney instead of arguing that your view must be correct....
Maya
|
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pirate Bood
When Davy Burnrat put his question to the court on wednesday night it was a valid question and remains unresolved.
In this case I too, coming from the perspective of the 'under dog' sought the reassurance from the court with regard to an issue ....
BUT
As a court we have to decide on whether its fair for those of us who are not prepared to break with Disney rules and protocol (whether that be for security reasons or for moral reasons) to be OBLIGED to, in order to keep up in these events add a talk programme, which as Roxanna has pointed out is entered into at our own risks.
Maya Mara
|
And in Davey's own words:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Davey Burnrat
.... I just ask that it not be used in the contest so everyone else that uses it will be on a level playing field.... Davy
|
Reassurance was requested that those choosing not to violate Disney TOS would not have to compete in TBC events where others were playing the voice/chat prg advantage.
The answer came back from TBC that whilst TBC would not condone the use of any method of violation of the DISNEY rules players are to use their own discretion as to whether they do use the prg which is the SUBJECT of he original question.
This offered no reasurance to those concerned, so the onus was put upon those who were in need of reassurance in the first place. Inform us if the prgs will be used and let all decide whether or not to participate in TBC events so that we do not have to feel obliged to make any kind of violation or compromise our own security to compete in them.
Maya
Quote:
Originally Posted by Tobias_Walker
Well maybe its time to speak up here...number one...i realize this is an open forum...and anyone can speak. Davy has brought this up, and he is not a member of the bretheren court...since his guild pretty much disolved he created his own....
Which he showed up at the court meeting as a member of his new guild which was not an approved guild. He then proceded to take the floor and and put this to the court?? How So??
Also if you check and watch us...(the Sharks) youll see that the vista clock glitch has been sinking us time after time....
|
Davey had permission to talk at the event as granted by Roxanna, all attendees at the event are permitted to comment, non members cannot vote.
Since Davey motioned this point when he was still in a member guild and hopes that his own guild will be members also then your point is unfair and ungrounded.
TBC does not support the accusations from one guild to another of any form of cheating please be reminded of The Brethren Court Codex :
Article I, Section I, Paragraph I
All guilds participating in the Brethren Court agree to be respectful to ALL guilds and guild mates represented by the alliance. Harassment and accusations against other guilds will not be tolerated. We are all here to work together for the benefit of all pirates looking to make a difference.
AND ALSO
Article I, Section II, Paragraph I
Mates not respecting the Code will be subject to reprimand by their Guild Master, including Demotion, Suspension from the Guild or a BAN from the Guild depending on the severity of Disruption(s).
TBC
Maya Mara
Keeper of the Court