Keeping in mind the new update about to hit open I'd like to see the following:
Peg Legs
Eye Patches
Hooks
New Ship Types
A Pirate Flag for me ship
More islands
New things to use my cutlass against! (How about Zombies?)
More Quests
The Flying Dutchman Roaming around as a Flag Ship With Davy Jones at the Helm!
Boss Flag Ships
Heck More Flag Ships!
Why Can't I capture a ship and keep it? Or Sell it?
Maybe a Parrot too!
This all would be nice!