To me, a perfect guild has to be active, with at least 10 or more people. Size doesn't really matter to me. My guild, Bandidos Are Back, was derived from my old guild, El Bandidos. It had 300 people. I took a big look at that guild, and I saw that I was leading incorrectly. All the people in my guild, or the majority, were only basics that came on once or twice. I took my active people and created Bandidos Are Back, which is very active. We loot, fish, and do Practice SvS. My guild is also a military guild. We never attack other guilds, unless we are attacked. So, overall, size now does not matter to me. As long as the people in your guild are happy, your guild is healthy.