Ok, I'm entering this contest!
Isle of the Blue Sands
The Blue Sands would OBVIOUSLY have blue sand. It would have a small hut, hidden by the lush undergrowth of the island. There would also be a HUGE cave and a small town. The cave would be called, "Cave of the Golden Idol". You could get a quest (At lvl 30) to go in there and find the Golden Idol. Inside the cave there are Skeletons, a couple Navy, skeletons, (For decoration) and Jolly Roger's twin brother. (IDK his name yet, but when i think of it i will POST IT) It would be much like Outcast Isle, just a cave, town, and no enemies.
Well, thats about it. I cant think of anything because the town takes up most of the island, and the town is like Tortuga, except smaller.