[Captain Hector]

I've dreamed of this

Spoiler for My weapon ideas:

Red Dagger
Legendary Throwing Knives
Attack: 52
Ability: Red Fire Attack- 50% more attack damage and 25% chance dodging an attack, +5 Sidewander
Story: The Red Dagger was made by the Navy, but got captured by Jolly Roger's goons. They added the "special" curse.

Dark Staff
Famed Staff
Aurora: Boosts attack for all pirates near by
Attack: 42
Ability: Black Aurora- Damages every enemy in area by 50 HP and 15 voodoo, +10 Wither
Story: Tia Dalma's staff gone wrong. She buried it on Cuba, later to be discovered by pirates.

Blue Cursed Fire Musket
Famed Musket
Attack: 72
Ability: Blue Fire Shot- Fires a blue flaming bullet that sets fire to an enemy OR ship for 7 seconds, +5 silver shot, +4 take aim
Story: Made by the darkest pirate on a secret Lava Lair on Padres Del Fuego. It later got stolen by Undead Raiders, and it's location is now unknown.

Earthen Sword
Rare Broadsword
Attack: 62
Ability: Vine Wrap- Wrap the enemy in vines for 12 seconds, +2 Brawl
Story: Will Turner's finest blade. With a magical enchantment, of course.

Sun Drop Doll
Famed Doll
Attack: 68
Ability: Blind your enemy! Lasts 7 seconds., +6 Life Drain
Story: A heavenly stick from the heavens, draped with cloth and able to attune enemies.

Spoiler for My dream sword::

Aquatic Broadsword
Legendary Broadsword
Attack: 125
Ability: Mini Tsunami erupts from the sword. Causes 1,000 damage to any enemy nearby, +15 Blade storm, +3 Roundhouse
Story: Brewed in the ancient forge of Poseidon and hidden beneath the ocean waves for centuries, and eventually washed up on the shores of Tortuga.

Glad I learned how to make a Spoiler, or else it might've taken up room.
Thanks for the thread!
(notice how some weapons have more than +5)