I voted #2... but actually have not been playing recently...
On test and when it first went live - you couldn't get me off SvS
I think when played fairly (before the glitches) it was great - the perfect addition for me to spend bucketloads of money on ammo on...
It is so unfortunate I - just once - didn't hit the F1 key by accident or on purpose when repairing my boat on test all them times I was playing there. I just never thought about it... I mean - I'm sailing, I'm testing EVERY sailing thing to try and glitch (and discovered the Hidden Rock on the left of the Spanish Isle) and reported every imbalence I could find... but NEVER though about hitting F1....
I didn't even realise it until today - but its been 3 weeks since I've done SvS. Now - RL has been very busy, but when it first came out I found 20 minutes a day at least to do a 'quick round'... then it just stopped being fun with the glitches.
In the end - I guess I'll still just keep sending in my reports, keep doing my tests, and hope that the devs are in the background working out the solution...