POTCO will be the game I play - its +'s are its ease of use, and the sea battles (more so in crews and boarding ships) is really top notch (of course I hope they continue to put more resources towards bugs - this is it biggest cripple at the moment - but not big enough they just got more money out of me to extend my membership... again
)
POTBS I checked it because even though I don't play it - I do know many that do. It is set up for the older folks - economy, large sailing, many directions - and the graphics are REALLY hard to beat (then ships alone looks so real). Of course, the drawback can be its complexity (I don't have time to run an economy and play and trade and all that - I ust want to do pretty focused questing and play
)