Ok, here's my contribution to your manual Grace. I left off anything you already have listed, hope it helps
VAULABLES
Brass Locket
Small Diamond
Copper Bits
Pearl Strand
Jade Toe Ring
ODDS & ENDS
Mouse Carving
Cricket In Amber
Protection Charm
Sextant
Eerie Statue (Just received)
NINE ROUGES
Valleneva
NAVY DECORATIONS
Conspicuous Attendence
Good Conduct Medal
Distinguished Obedience Pin
Obsequious Order Badge
Illustrious Baton
Effort Ribbon
Veteran Insignia
RUDYARD'S TEETH
Central Incisor - 2 (Found I had 2 on my other pirate)
Canine
Bicuspid - 3
Second Molar - 2
*NOTE: As you can see, some teeth require more than one*
RHINEWORTH'S RINGS
Left Ring Finger
Left Index Finger
Right Index Finger
Right Middle Finger
Right Ring Finger
TREASURE CHESS
Silver Queen
Gold Knight
Gold Bishop - 2
Gold Rook
*NOTE: Like Rudyard's Teeth, most pieces will require more than one to complete the set*
TIA DALMA'S MENAGERIE
Aligator Figure
Wasp Figure
Fly Figure
Snake Figure
Good luck with the rest of the manual.