there was an earlier thread on this and a couple of other quests - doc grog was one that was suggested not to start because it seems to be bugged - nobody can complete it. I have one of my pirates stuck on it and although I have all the items, he has yet to let me complete it... I find it interesting that NONE of the quests in Chap 3 seems completeable (I know that isn't a real word! - LOL) at this point they seem to concentrating on graphic issues - I am hoping with the next "build" they will have figured out the graphics problem and be able to focus on the quests... at any rate, you are not alone!
irate.smiley.capta