POTC vs LOTR

[Midhav]

POTC over LOTR though both are good. POTC is made up of comedy, a good cast & crew, awesome graphics, explorable storylines and are amazing. When i saw POTC2&3 first i didnt like it, but when i saw it a few more times ( and played POTCO and wikied it ), i liked it!
But the ultimate villain thing is kinda split between Beckett ( ruthless, cruel, evil, but not gifted with supernatural powers ), and Davy Jones ( cruel, powerful, somewhat ruthless, yet lost so easilly and is weak in the heart for love ), whereas Sauron is so pure evil along with the Wich King, and the very thought of Morgoth...