Which weapon is better?

[William ORoberts]

It depends on your stats, and what kind of skill points you have on what. If you are like me, a higher level, with venom shot and take aim maxxed, I would go with the pirate blunderbuss. If you are a lower level that will maiinly use lead shot, the healing and boosts on the swashbuckler blunderbuss will probably seem more useful. Have you tested them each for a while to see which one you prefer using? If you don't find one to be a lot better than the other, I would keep both.