Catching a Legendary Fish

[CaptainMonkeys]

Originally Posted by Sven Osymthe

Boat location and the section you use don't matter. Just keep the lure moving around in the bottom right area for as long as possible.

Only reason I say location doesn't matter, one story said the fish would be by Tortuga, yet it is anywhere. And on top of that, every time you enter and exit a location, the fishes are slightly different.

What about the one that appears in the fog?? That might be a clue...