Which movie was better?

[FoolsLove]

Second one all the way. Though you can't help but love them both.

[soccergals]

I prefered the first; it was so much more fun to watch, and I had no idea what to expect with it.

[Qui-gon]

I like the first one better, it's a classic. But the second one is really, really good.

~Q/S

[Garfieldo]

Originally Posted by LoveDefying

Second one all the way. Though you can't help but love them both.

Agreed, agreed. The first was great, but there's just something about the second that makes it so much better...

[PinkPinkNicole]

The first was one was a lot more fun, in my opinion.
Elizabeth was too confusing in the second one >_<

[PrincessNicolle]

I love both movies and I am really getting excited about the third one! But I like the original best.

[futuremartymcfly]

I preffered the first. The second movie really got long and tiring towards the end. I can't say wether I would have chosen Captain Blood, however, as I haven't yet seen any Errol Flynn flicks.

[HaveAMagicalDay]

after seeing the third one, i like the first one still... lol

~Cpt.Sea

[warner]

I have to say out of all three that I have seen, I choose the second. I just didn't get the third one when Tia Dalma was talking all the time, she was just next to impossible to understand, and there was one part where she just talked for a long time, that was crazy. I will buy the third on DVD and use the sub-titles to see what she said, once I have seen the third one again, I will probably say that one. But for now, it's the second. On the first movie, I think it had plenty of action, but not nearly as much as the second and third, but none-the-less, a great story.


-warner


P.S. I think the third one was more funny, even though Pintel and Raggeti weren't as good as they were in the second and first.