New or old port royal

[Captain Del]

Old Port Royal, all the way. I just became attached to the islands my pirate grew up on

[MacIronhawk]

I like the new one more, but the landscape of the first was more like the movie, which it should be.

I'd like to see them add in a long piece of land and two skeletons being hanged by the ropes like in the movies, just so we get the sense that we're in the movie, and not just some horrible copy.

[Basil Dreadflint]

Old PR. Hands down!! The old PR was much more fun than the new one. There were way more cool things you could do on it. And the flow through the cave system was better.