Catching a Legendary Fish

[Beorn]

The clicking on the handle is the hardest for me. You just need to catch it once to stop the fish from running away. I am going to say that it is the same for each fish, but not necessarily the same order. I have caught Speedy lou, struggle and reel a bunch with one catch the handle, and I've lost to Glittering Girl twice. I had a few catch the handles with her. Just keep at it mate and you'll get them eventually.