Get The Lost Sword of El Patron

[Captain Jason]

Ah ha! You have fogotten one thing though davy fireskull, since El Patron gives you the sword you basically take his place, and are killed. Therefore you aren't alive to have the sword in the first place. It is still the lost sword of davy fireskull, but now everyone knows that name for exactly what el patron was. Since you disappear, I get the sword before anyone else can and go underwater with a straw that nobody will find.

Originally Posted by KeeperOfTheCode

Alright then, but of course, you realize that in going back in time, you actually split space-time into three parts. Only in one of them do you actually own the sword. I, on this plane of reality which remains fairly unchanged from the time you left, take the Lost Sword of El Patron (since you took what is now the 'Lost Sword of Davy Fireskull' before he died he never cursed it and therefore it is practically worthless anyway) and fly off to my 'home dimension', where my pirate was born from the abyssal nastiness so long ago. My other-world counterparts also do this, and we escape into the multiverse, each carrying a piece of the sword.
(P.S. You have to explain how you got back the sword parts, don't just say 'I got it back'.

If you want me to explain my logic, just ask. From now on in-game, unfortunately, we'll have to post what our two alternate-reality selves did with the swords.

I'd like an explanation