Have you actually seen the movies?

[Tiberius Fireskull]

Perhaps the movie wont be bad, but I think that it is going to be too different.... Will Turner is my favorite character by far, and not seeing him come back is a heartbreak for me (no not because I love him, he is just an amazing character). The reason the second and third movies are so different from the first is that first movies tend to always be introduction movies. To set the scene, characters, etc. Star Wars was like that wasn't it? The Phantom Menace really just set the scene for what was to come. I agree, maybe it won't be too bad, but it will be extremely different... and I don't think I will like that too much....

Oh how I love debate!