best weapon for pvp?

[Captain Sharktooth]

I don't see a problem with dolls, I mean it's Pirate Vs. Pirate, doll is a standard weapon so it annoys me when peoples say it's cheating. It's really not, you're allowed to use whatever weapon you want. And there are ways to shake off the attunement, running away, or using dagger. The best weapon would be either doll or broadsword, for me.

[GhostlyOtto]

I would use a musket loaded with steel shot to weaken or kill them from a distance. If they get close after that use a broadsword to finish them. Using a voodoo doll is fine. If someone tries to use one on you use viper's nest or asp to stop them.