POTC or POTC 2?

[Ducky Wucky]

Originally Posted by icecoolio

Elizabeth fights better than Will and Jack combined... @_@
Also, I personally think her outfit was the best designed costume in the movie.

Yeah, I'm getting a little worried about her new costume in this movie coming up. I saw a picture, and it looked a little bit awkward. O_o

[JohnnyGunflint]

Originally Posted by Ducky Wucky

Yeah, I'm getting a little worried about her new costume in this movie coming up. I saw a picture, and it looked a little bit awkward. O_o

What'd it look like? Too revealing? Too girly? Too piratey (as if that's possible )?

[Ducky Wucky]

Originally Posted by icecoolio

What'd it look like? Too revealing? Too girly? Too piratey (as if that's possible )?

I'm not sure how to explain, it just didn't look right. O_o

[JohnnyGunflint]

Originally Posted by Ducky Wucky

I'm not sure how to explain, it just didn't look right. O_o

Well, for now, I'll have to imagine it.

[warner]

Well, this is a tough choice but I have to say the second movie. It had more action and it was an all around better movie to me. I do agree with icecoolio that this explains what Pirates of The Carribean is really about. And the second was much more creative to me.

And Elizabeth.. Better than Jack and Will? No, sorry, but Jack Sparrow is probably better than Will and Elizabeth together.

Oh, and nice signature Ducky.

-warner

[JohnnyGunflint]

Originally Posted by warner

Well, this is a tough choice but I have to say the second movie. It had more action and it was an all around better movie to me. I do agree with icecoolio that this explains what Pirates of The Carribean is really about. And the second was much more creative to me.

And Elizabeth.. Better than Jack and Will? No, sorry, but Jack Sparrow is probably better than Will and Elizabeth together.

Oh, and nice signature Ducky.

-warner

I agree that the second movie had a lot of good action, but don't you think that they kinda focused on that? I would like a better plot like the first one's.

Just my opinion.

[Ducky Wucky]

Originally Posted by icecoolio

I agree that the second movie had a lot of good action, but don't you think that they kinda focused on that? I would like a better plot like the first one's.

Just my opinion.

It's like The Lord of the Rings. The first one had almost no fighting in it, and the second one had a TON of fighting in it. That's just how movies are made today. That's all there is to it.

[JohnnyGunflint]

Originally Posted by Ducky Wucky

It's like The Lord of the Rings. The first one had almost no fighting in it, and the second one had a TON of fighting in it. That's just how movies are made today. That's all there is to it.

Point taken. I do hope some extravegant director will someday take movies in a new direction.
But still, POTC and LOTR are still good movie series, of course.

[Crimsonite]

I would have to go with POTC because that movie was good throughout the entire movie, while I did not like the beginning and ending of POTC 2.